The European Court of Justice has ruled that HGV drivers may not take full 45 hour weekly rest periods in the cabs of their vehicles, and that national governments are entitled to penalise drivers who contravene that prohibition.
The ruling was made following a Belgian case involving an operator whose driver had been issued with an 1,800.00 Euro fine for taking a full weekly rest in the cab of his vehicle. The operator appealed on the basis that there was nothing in the EU Drivers Hours Regulation (EC) 561/2006 which specifically prohibits a driver from doing so - and, therefore, that the state had no legal power to issue penalties.
The Belgian appeals court hearing the case referred it to the European Court, seeking a ruling on whether the EC Drivers' Hours Regs should be interpreted as meaning that drivers may not take full weekly rests in vehicle cabs (and if yes, whether it is lawful under European Charter principles for any nation state to criminalise taking full weekly rest periods in cabs given that the EC Regs do not specifically prohibit it).
The European Court looked closely at the EC Regulation - and in particular, its overall objective which includes seeking "...to improve working conditions and road safety" and concluded that the Regulation was intended to prohibit taking full weekly rests in cabs (the Regulation makes it clear that daily rests and REDUCED weekly rest periods may be taken in vehicle cabs, as long as the cab is suitably equipped).
The Court ruled that Member States are entitled to put in place national measures to prohibit drivers taking full weekly rests in cabs and to punish contraventions, despite there being no specific reference to any offence in the EC Regulation.
UK operators should be aware that under domestic law, the DVSA now has powers to issue fixed penalty fines where drivers take full weekly rests in vehicle cabs: presently, according to DVSA guidance, fines will only be issued where those weekly rests are taken in areas where there is no access to toilets, showers or food facilities - it remains to be seen whether in the light of this decision, national measures will be stepped up to include an outright prohibition on any full weekly rest being taken in the cab (but it seems likely that this will be the consequence).
Our advice is that full weekly rests should always be taken away from the vehicle cab at a place where there are proper facilities to ensure comfort and adequate rest for the driver.
If you would like any further information on this issue or any other issue affecting your business, then call us now on 01279 818280.
February 2018
More News and Insight
Moving to a Digital First Approach in Heavy Vehicle Testing
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyTraffic Commissioner Highlights Abuse of Section-19 Permits
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyEnero Logistics Ltd – the Law for Operators on Agency Drivers
At one time or another, many transport companies need to rely on the services provided by agency drivers, to best cope with sudden fluctuations in demand or to fill driver shortages. This allows for the undisrupted continuation of services by these organisations.
by Emma PellyAre you Up To Date with the Guidance on Right to Work Checks?
In August 2023, it was announced that from 2024 the penalties imposed on employers who are found to be employing people who do not have a right to work in the UK would be tripled, in an effort to curb this “black-market” practice and raise the disincentives for people to come to the UK to live and work illegally.
by Emma PellyDriver CPC Reform: Department For Transport Publishes Consultation Findings
In early 2022 the Department of Transport (DfT) launched a consultation into the Driver Certificate of Professional Competence (DCPC) regime, following a review undertaken in late 2021 on the driver shortage issues.
by Emma PellyHydrogen Powered Vehicles – DVSA statutory testing
In early August 2023, the Driver & Vehicles Standards Agency (‘DVSA’) posted a bulletin regarding statutory testing of Hydrogen powered vehicles.
by Emma PellyTransport for London found Guilty of “Procedural Impropriety”
The case of Transport for London (TfL) vs. Commercial Plant Services Ltd & Others 2023 (“Commercial Plant”) recently hit the headlines as the London Tribunal ruled that TfL “broke the law” when it used CCTV systems rather than Civil Enforcement Officers (CEOs) to issue Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) to drivers.
by Emma PellyDepartment of Transport Funding £8m to Improve Truck Roadside Facilities
The Department for Transport (DfT) has recently announced the “winners” of its £8 million funding offered to bidders to ensure better roadside facilities, more secure parking and improved rest areas.
by Emma PellyLoading Safely – New Guidance from the DVSA
The DVSA has recently updated its guidance on safe loading of vehicles – something which they believe should be of primary concern for all road users, whether it is using a seatbelt to secure passengers in a family car or transporting goods in lorries.
by Emma PellyGovernment Publishes Review into Traffic Commissioner Function
During 2021 and 2022 the government ran a review into the Traffic Commissioner Function in the UK. The report into this review was published at the end of May 2023.
by Emma PellyLonger Lorries now Allowed on UK Roads
Legislation passed by the UK Government which came into force on 31st May 2023 sees the introduction to Great Britain’s roads of longer semi-trailer (LST) combinations of up to 18.55 metres, a full 2.05 metres longer than previously allowed.
by Emma PellyPSVAR Review – Call for Evidence
Under-Secretary of State for Transport, Richard Holden has urged members of the coach and bus industry to respond to the government’s call for evidence (CfE) in a key review on the Public Services Vehicles Accessibility Regulations (PSVAR) which were introduced in 2000.
by Emma Pelly