Changes to the HGV & PSV Test Regime for Earned Recognition Operators
In March 2021 the Government began a review into the processes for commercial vehicle testing to look at ways it could improve the regime for operators whilst still maintaining high safety standards for any vehicle used commercially on the UK’s roads.
The outcome to that review was published earlier this year with four proposed options for changing the testing regime for operators who hold the DVSA’s Earned Recognition status. Click here to read the full document.
The DVSA earned recognition for vehicle operators is a voluntary scheme within the UK, for PSV & HGV operators to “prove” that they are meeting both the driver and vehicle standards required by the regulatory regime. In return for sharing information about the maintenance and performance of the vehicles the company owns, with them, the DVSA “promises” to be less likely to stop your vehicles for inspections. When it works, Earned Recognition status saves “ER” operators time and money by keeping your vehicles on the road and giving the DVSA confidence that Earned Recognition vehicles are safe and compliant.
The four proposed options were as follows:
- Option 1: Increasing the time between tests for earned recognition operators.
- Remove the requirement for ER operators to have vehicles tested every 12 months.
- Option 2: Delegated testing
- Allow ER operators to test their own vehicles and trailers.
- Option 3: Reduced test content
- Reduce test content, such a removing some items that are covered in routine inspections, or in the longer term, those that can be effectively monitored by in-vehicle systems.
- Option 4: Improved service provision
- The DVSA could focus its service improvement on ER operators, for example, by giving complete or greater guarantee of requested authorised test facility slots and greater flexibility around days and hours worked to match maintenance requirements.
What Responses did the Department for Transport Received?
The Department for Transport received 49 formal responses from operators and six additional written submissions, and of those respondents a total of 59% of those who did respond stated that the current testing regime for earned recognition operators should be altered.
The most popular option for changes to the annual testing regime was the option to delegate testing (option 2), which made up 42% of the overall vote. Second came the option of increasing the time between tests for ER operators (option one) with 34% of the vote. Options three and four garnered just 12% each and as a result, both have since been dropped from further consideration by the Department for Transport.
Commenting on the review outcome, The Department for Transport has stated that increasing the time between tests would help reduce “unproductive time whilst awaiting tests” and that there was “moderate” support for this option among those who had responded, but that there was a strong view that changing the frequency of vehicle testing could increase road safety risks if not “supervised properly and without adequate safeguards”.
The responses on Option 2 – delegating of testing were generally positive. This option would maintain the volume of data feeding into the ER scheme, but it would mean that it is not under the control of the DVSA and may not provide an independent review of maintenance undertaken by the operator. They go on to state that for many ER operators, there would only be a benefit with this option if “sub-delegating” of testing by ER operators to 3rd parties was possible, which would just add yet more complexity into the testing regime.
Options 1 and 2 have the benefits of increasing choice for ER operators and allowing more opportunities to reduce unproductive time awaiting tests. They also help with scheduling issues but set against these possible benefits are the concerns around lessening or possibly removing roadworthiness data and also a real worry about increasing road safety risks.
Some “non-ER” operators argued that all vehicles should be subject to the same testing regime and that the Earned Recognition Scheme for operators already has many benefits – chief amongst these the promise not to be pulled over by the DVSA for roadside inspections - testing of vehicles should not be one of them.
Next Steps for the Review?
The Department for Transport is suggesting further work should be done on Option One (increasing time between tests for ER Operators) and that further assessment on the following areas should be undertaken:
- Whether lessening testing frequency will result in a reduction in in-use condition of vehicles between those tests and whether changes to the ER scheme could mitigate any such risk,
- How to ensure ER continues to have sufficient data to be effective in identifying highly compliant operators with safe operating practices,
- Whether ER should be put on a statutory footing in association with any test changes,
- Whether to require a test to have been completed within the last year for vehicles used in international circulation,
- The position of vehicles (tractors and trailers) which move between ER and non-ER operators,
- The position of vehicles of operators who lose their ER status, and
- The procedures to implement the option for both HGVs and PSVs.
If you have any questions regarding the changes discussed in this article, or questions about your eligibility for the earned recognition operator scheme, or vehicle maintenance in general, then please click here to send us an email, or call us directly on 01279 818280. We are here to help.
(c) Richard Pelly, May 2024
More News and Insight
Changes to the HGV & PSV Test Regime for Earned Recognition Operators
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyEmployment Law Updates for 2024
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyCampaign to Bar Schools from using Section 19 Permits
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyMoving to a Digital First Approach in Heavy Vehicle Testing
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyTraffic Commissioner Highlights Abuse of Section-19 Permits
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyEnero Logistics Ltd – the Law for Operators on Agency Drivers
At one time or another, many transport companies need to rely on the services provided by agency drivers, to best cope with sudden fluctuations in demand or to fill driver shortages. This allows for the undisrupted continuation of services by these organisations.
by Emma PellyAre you Up To Date with the Guidance on Right to Work Checks?
In August 2023, it was announced that from 2024 the penalties imposed on employers who are found to be employing people who do not have a right to work in the UK would be tripled, in an effort to curb this “black-market” practice and raise the disincentives for people to come to the UK to live and work illegally.
by Emma PellyDriver CPC Reform: Department For Transport Publishes Consultation Findings
In early 2022 the Department of Transport (DfT) launched a consultation into the Driver Certificate of Professional Competence (DCPC) regime, following a review undertaken in late 2021 on the driver shortage issues.
by Emma PellyHydrogen Powered Vehicles – DVSA statutory testing
In early August 2023, the Driver & Vehicles Standards Agency (‘DVSA’) posted a bulletin regarding statutory testing of Hydrogen powered vehicles.
by Emma PellyTransport for London found Guilty of “Procedural Impropriety”
The case of Transport for London (TfL) vs. Commercial Plant Services Ltd & Others 2023 (“Commercial Plant”) recently hit the headlines as the London Tribunal ruled that TfL “broke the law” when it used CCTV systems rather than Civil Enforcement Officers (CEOs) to issue Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) to drivers.
by Emma PellyDepartment of Transport Funding £8m to Improve Truck Roadside Facilities
The Department for Transport (DfT) has recently announced the “winners” of its £8 million funding offered to bidders to ensure better roadside facilities, more secure parking and improved rest areas.
by Emma PellyLoading Safely – New Guidance from the DVSA
The DVSA has recently updated its guidance on safe loading of vehicles – something which they believe should be of primary concern for all road users, whether it is using a seatbelt to secure passengers in a family car or transporting goods in lorries.
by Emma Pelly