As has been widely reported in the recent trade press, 1st January 2020 is a date which looms large on the horizon for coach operators: this is the date that the final provisions of the Public Service Vehicle Accessibility Regulations 2000 ("PSVAR") - which relate specifically to coaches designed to carry more than 22 passengers registered before 2000 - take effect. These provisions are likely to affect a number of operators using older coaches for certain journeys - in particular, home to school transport provision.
By way of a whistle-stop reminder: PSVAR is a piece of legislation which prescribes accessibility requirements for public service vehicles. Since the regulations' inception in 2000, the general position has been that all new buses and coaches designed to carry more than 22 passengers used on local or scheduled services have been required to be fully accessible in accordance with the terms of the regulations.
Initially, vehicles which were manufactured before October 2000 were exempt, but the legislation was drafted in such a way as to allow for a staged roll-out for older vehicles, with different categories of vehicle being captured by the requirements of the regulations from a series of set dates. 1st January 2020 is the last of those dates, and older coaches are the last vehicles to be brought in-scope.
The Accessibility Requirements Themselves
Once the application of the regulations can be established, the accessibility requirements themselves are relatively straightforward, albeit subject to detailed technical specification. From 1st January 2020, all affected coaches in use will require certificates confirming conformity to the provisions of both Schedule 1 and Schedule 3 of the Regulations. Schedule 1 deals with wheelchair accessibility requirements, while Schedule 3 deals with more general accessibility requirements including, among other, specifications for seats, steps, floors/gangways and handrails.
Application of PSVAR to Coaches - Local and Scheduled Services
As above, the starting point is that for the purposes of the regulations, a "coach" is defined as a public service vehicle designed and constructed to carry more than 22 seated passengers: so coaches designed to carry 22 or fewer passengers are always exempt.
A vehicle to which the regulations apply is said to be "used" or "in use" when being used to provide either a local service or a scheduled service.
A "local service" is defined as in the Transport Act 1985; in short, the carriage of passengers at separate fares, unless (in simple terms) stops are 15 or more miles apart, or unless the service meets the condition of Part III, Schedule 1 of the Public Passenger Vehicles Act 1981 (i.e. comprises of a trip organised privately by persons acting independently of vehicle operators). Vehicles operated under Section 19 permits are exempted in this definition (but in fact are specifically exempted by PSVAR in any case).
A "scheduled service' means a service for the carriage of passengers at separate fares along specified routes, at specified times, with passengers being taken up and set down at pre-determined stopping points, with the exception of tours (i.e. a service in which the vehicle is used for carrying passengers to a location or numerous locations and then back to the departure point).
To complete the picture, the regulations provide a list of further exemptions: in addition to vehicles operated under section 19 permits, there are specific exemptions for off-road vehicles, vehicles designed for carrying the sick and injured, prisoner vehicles, and government or Crown vehicles. Perhaps of most relevance to coach operators is an exemption which applies to coaches which were first used on a road more than 20 years ago and which are not used to provide a local or scheduled services for more than 20 days in a year.
Those legal definitions and exemptions in themselves do not necessarily cause trouble until one begins to consider their application to practical situations - in particular, what is meant by "separate fares". And therein lies the problem for operators, and the root cause of the concern widely reported in recent trade press.
Separate Fares
In basic terms, a fare is any payment which is made for matters including the right to be carried on a vehicle - whether directly or indirectly, and no matter who the fare is paid to. For example, students of a private school for which the fees paid include a home to school transport provision (even where a payment explicitly for transport is not made) undoubtedly would be viewed as paying separate fares.
School Transport
The issue most likely to affect operators is whether the provision of home to school transport will be defined as a local or scheduled service. Again, this may turn on whether separate fares are charged.
The general position is that where transport is provided to the user free of charge (which is the case for a number of schoolchildren who are eligible for free travel), then the regulations do not apply. However, it is not uncommon for local authorities to sell spare seats on vehicles to fee-paying passengers. Where this is the case, a separate fare is paid, thus the journey will fall in-scope (assuming that the other features of the journey make it a local or scheduled service - which, for many home to school journeys is likely to be the case). It only requires one passenger paying a separate fare to require the vehicle to comply with the regulations.
There is a school of thought suggesting that a home to school service could be described as a "tour" given that, in the course of a day, passengers are taken to a specific location and returned to their point of departure (and as above, tours are exempt) - but this has yet to be tested by the courts, and operators would be well advised not to seek to rely on this interpretation - a court is likely to conclude that this plainly was not the intention of the regulations.
Options for Operators and Local Authorities
First and foremost, operators need to know whether journeys are in-scope or not, which means knowing whether end-users are being charged separate fares - this is especially the case for local authority home to school service provision. As soon as any passenger is paying a fare (directly or indirectly), the regulations will apply, and operators need to be sure that they are informed of passengers' fare-paying arrangements by local authorities.
Operators may be in a position to rely on one of the specified exemptions from the regulations. Using a fleet of smaller coaches with 22 or fewer passenger seats would obviously achieve this (though in practice, this is likely to be impractical). Ensuring that vehicles first used over 20 years ago are not used on more than 20 days per year for local or scheduled services is another - albeit that given the nature of home to school transport, such infrequent use is unlikely to be possible.
For local authorities, offering free home to school transport across the board - even where children are not automatically eligible - is one theoretical resolution which will mean operators they contract with can continue to use non-PSVAR compliant coaches, but plainly this is a resolution that is unlikely to be commercially viable.
Where the regulations do apply, operators will realistically be left with two options: ensuring that coaches not captured by the regulations prior to 1 January 2020 are compliant with the accessibility requirements from that date (which in many cases may mean either costly retrofits or replacing vehicles) - or else switching coaches for already-compliant buses for all local or scheduled services where separate fares are paid.
Ultimately, of course, the regulations are intended to ensure equality of access for public service vehicles. Reputationally speaking, there is of course much to be said for ensuring that your vehicles are compliant.
If you need any further advice or assistance with this issue then please call us on 01279 818280 or click here to send an email.
(C) Richard Pelly - first appeared in Croner-i Passenger Transport, December 2019.
More News and Insight
Traffic Commissioner Highlights Abuse of Section-19 Permits
In a Section 19 Public Inquiry hearing heard last year (2023) the Traffic Commissioner highlighted again the importance of permit operators ensuring that their vehicles allow passengers and other road users to be safe.
by Emma PellyEnero Logistics Ltd – the Law for Operators on Agency Drivers
At one time or another, many transport companies need to rely on the services provided by agency drivers, to best cope with sudden fluctuations in demand or to fill driver shortages. This allows for the undisrupted continuation of services by these organisations.
by Emma PellyAre you Up To Date with the Guidance on Right to Work Checks?
In August 2023, it was announced that from 2024 the penalties imposed on employers who are found to be employing people who do not have a right to work in the UK would be tripled, in an effort to curb this “black-market” practice and raise the disincentives for people to come to the UK to live and work illegally.
by Emma PellyDriver CPC Reform: Department For Transport Publishes Consultation Findings
In early 2022 the Department of Transport (DfT) launched a consultation into the Driver Certificate of Professional Competence (DCPC) regime, following a review undertaken in late 2021 on the driver shortage issues.
by Emma PellyHydrogen Powered Vehicles – DVSA statutory testing
In early August 2023, the Driver & Vehicles Standards Agency (‘DVSA’) posted a bulletin regarding statutory testing of Hydrogen powered vehicles.
by Emma PellyTransport for London found Guilty of “Procedural Impropriety”
The case of Transport for London (TfL) vs. Commercial Plant Services Ltd & Others 2023 (“Commercial Plant”) recently hit the headlines as the London Tribunal ruled that TfL “broke the law” when it used CCTV systems rather than Civil Enforcement Officers (CEOs) to issue Penalty Charge Notices (PCNs) to drivers.
by Emma PellyDepartment of Transport Funding £8m to Improve Truck Roadside Facilities
The Department for Transport (DfT) has recently announced the “winners” of its £8 million funding offered to bidders to ensure better roadside facilities, more secure parking and improved rest areas.
by Emma PellyLoading Safely – New Guidance from the DVSA
The DVSA has recently updated its guidance on safe loading of vehicles – something which they believe should be of primary concern for all road users, whether it is using a seatbelt to secure passengers in a family car or transporting goods in lorries.
by Emma PellyGovernment Publishes Review into Traffic Commissioner Function
During 2021 and 2022 the government ran a review into the Traffic Commissioner Function in the UK. The report into this review was published at the end of May 2023.
by Emma PellyLonger Lorries now Allowed on UK Roads
Legislation passed by the UK Government which came into force on 31st May 2023 sees the introduction to Great Britain’s roads of longer semi-trailer (LST) combinations of up to 18.55 metres, a full 2.05 metres longer than previously allowed.
by Emma PellyPSVAR Review – Call for Evidence
Under-Secretary of State for Transport, Richard Holden has urged members of the coach and bus industry to respond to the government’s call for evidence (CfE) in a key review on the Public Services Vehicles Accessibility Regulations (PSVAR) which were introduced in 2000.
by Emma PellyDVSA Clarification of Use of HIAB Loader Lorries Maximum Length and Weight
The DVSA has recently highlighted some confusion about the use of “HIAB” loader lorries regarding the length and maximum weight of these vehicles.
by Emma Pelly